Albums That Flopped with Critics, Not with Fans

While Joshua Tree went to its fans, some critics found it too earnest. But its themes were the things of the heart that were incontestably heartfelt, and the vast sonic landscapes were created by U2 himself and his listeners loved.

“With or Without You” and “I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For” very much became anthems for many. Over the years, the album has congealed into a classic embodiment of the band’s legacy.