Matthew Is Getting The Information
Matthew started asking Michael when he was born. He was born on October the 5th in 1991. This was as important date as you shall see later on. Michael thought that there is no obvious reason why Matthew is asking too many questions.
Then Matthew asked him something that sounded a bit too specific. Every single question was designed to make Matthew closer to one event that happened almost 30 years ago. Matthew asked the cop where he was born precisely in Piscataway. It looked like Matthew knew something! It is bad!