Plausibility
Jimmy didn’t know what to do. He raised his children to be open and honest, but even this was too much to handle. A grown adult, a teacher no less, cutting a student’s hair?! His daughter’s hair?! That was even more implausible.
But Jimmy was about to find out it wasn’t implausible at all. He said that at that point, he and his wife consulted each other on what to do next. It’s not that they didn’t believe their daughter, they just wanted to get the full story, no matter how outrageous or unbelievable it may be!